Potato Cheese Soup- like Mom makes…

Growing up my FAVORITE soup was Potato Cheese Soup.

My mom made it the best.  Adding a little of this and that, no measuring.  That’s how she rolled.

I learned from the best.  😉

Well, when I moved out and needed some soup, I tried to make it.  Like Mom did.  But, it didn’t work out like I hoped.  I kept trying, and over the years I got closer to that childhood taste.  So, I finally set out to write down the recipe.  EACH and EVERY time I tried to figure the measurements, it just wasn’t right.

Since the birth of this blog, I have had an even deeper desire to get the recipe right.  But time and time again, I just wasn’t fully satisfied.

So, finally I gave up.  I thought forget it, I’m just going to make the soup for my family, and not get to share the recipe with my readers.

Guess what, the next time the soup turned out PERFECT!  SO, I racked my brain with what I had done to make it, and wrote the recipe.  I just had to trick myself, I guess.

So, I give you MY VERSION of my Mom’s potato cheese soup.

Potato Cheese Soup from Eat It and Say Yum

You might be asking ‘why is this Leia’s version, if she’s been trying duplicate her mom’s soup?’

Well, I was trying to match the taste and texture.  I’m pretty sure we use different methods to get to our end results.  And, my mom always used velveeta cheese.  And it gave the soup such a smooth and creamy texture.  But processed cheese isn’t so popular these days.  And I don’t have it on hand very often.  So, I changed that a bit.  (My mom has since changed cheeses, too.  But she did that after I moved out.)

Anyway, I wanted to use what I would normally have on hand.  So I used Parmesan cheese, and some Colby Jack.  But if I had different cheeses around, I wouldn’t hesitate to throw those in.  Cheese is so great, in that you can use a variety of kinds to get different flavors.  I love cheese.

Potato Cheese Soup from Eat It & Say Yum

This soup is so creamy.  I do use cream, but milk can be substituted for a lower calorie version.  I do that when I don’t have cream, or I’ll use both together.  Either way, it’s good.

Another thing I love about this soup is that my kids love it.  Winner, winner potato-cheese-soup dinner!  Err, something like that.

A meal my kids will eat without complaint is always a good thing.

Potato Cheese Soup- like Mom makes…

Potato Cheese Soup- like Mom makes…


  • 3 small- medium sized potatoes- diced
  • 2 carrots- diced
  • 2 1/2 Tbs butter
  • 3- 3 1/2 Tbs flour
  • 1/2 onion- diced
  • 1-2 cloves garlic- minced
  • 4 cups chicken broth
  • 1 1/2 cups cream (heavy cream or whipping cream)- milk can be substituted
  • 1/8 tsp dry mustard
  • dash or two paprika
  • salt and pepper to taste
  • 1/3 cup Parmesan cheese- grated
  • 1/2 cup cheddar cheese- grated (or any cheese you want- Colby-Jack, Pepper- Jack, white cheddar, etc.)


  1. In a medium pot over medium-high heat, boil enough water to cover the diced carrots and potatoes. Boil them until they are fork tender, but not mushy. Drain the water out and set the potatoes and carrots aside.
  2. In a larger pot, over medium-high heat, saute the diced onions and minced garlic in the butter, for about 2-3 minutes. Don’t let the butter burn, reduce heat if necessary. Add the flour and whisk it together with the butter and onions to make a roux. Slowly add the cream or milk, whisking while adding to make a smooth sauce. After the cream (or milk) is added slowly add the broth, whisking to keep everything smooth. Let the soup come to a slow boil.
  3. Add the dried mustard, paprika, pepper, potatoes and carrots into the large pot. Reduce the heat to a simmer. Add the cheese and whisk to combine everything. Now you can taste the soup and add enough salt to suit your tastes. Don’t add the salt before the cheese. Cheese, especially Parmesan cheese, can be very salty, so you don’t want to over power the soup with salt.
  4. Serve the soup while hot, with some bread or rolls for dipping.

Let me not forget our favorite breads to dip in this soup.

Dilly Bread

Dilly Bread from Eat It and Say Yum

Toasty Cheese and Bacon Bread

Toasty Cheese and Bacon Bread by Eat It & Say Yum

You might also like:

Chicken and Green Chile Soup

Chicken and Chile Soup from Eat It and Say Yum

Chicken Taco Soup

Chicken Taco Soup

Minestrone Soup with Italian Sausage

Minestrone Soup 402

18 thoughts on “Potato Cheese Soup- like Mom makes…

  1. What a great tip! Hello, my name is Misty, from The LadyPrefers2Save at http://theladypreferstosave.com, and I’m one of the new co-hosts for the Merry Monday Linky Party! I wanted to write and thank you for linking up to this weeks Merry Monday party, as well as to let you know that your post will be linked to the Merry Monday Pinterest board, as well my social media accounts. I would love to have you also stop by my blog as well! Thanks for linking up at the Merry Monday’s Linky Party this week, and I hope to see you linking up next week as well. Have an awesome week!

  2. I love potato soup and yours looks wonderful! I can’t wait to try it! Thank you so much for sharing it with us at Foodie Fridays! After a week off for Thanksgiving, we’ll be back this Thursday…I hope you will be joining us again! I’m pinning your wonderful soup!

  3. I really, really love this. And Yuck to Velveeta…I mean yum…bit it’s kinda gross 🙂 I featured this creamy goodness as one of my faves from last week’s #Foodie Fridays!!! Thanks for linking with us!!!! Glad to see your gorgeous pictures on there 🙂

Comments are closed.